Reconstructing Inquiry: A Pragmatist Perspective on the Logic of Archaeological Knowledge

  • Juan Carlo Del Razo Canuto Investigador Invitado en la EAHNM
Keywords: Archaeological inference, archaeological pragmatism, logic of inquiry, self-corrective inquiry, semiotics of inquiry

Abstract

This article develops a semiotics of archaeological inquiry grounded in the classical American pragmatism of Peirce and Dewey. It examines how knowledge about the past is constructed and validated, focusing on inquiry as a goal-oriented, self-corrective process structured by epistemic norms and contextual conditions. A comparative analysis of archaeological proposals explicitly associated with pragmatism, read against Peirce’s and Dewey’s principles, identifies a central divergence: these proposals tend to underdevelop the inferential logic and self-corrective character of scientific inquiry. The article formulates principles for reconstructing that logic by reintegrating abduction and the triadic relation among sign, object, and interpretant.

Author Biography

Juan Carlo Del Razo Canuto, Investigador Invitado en la EAHNM
I am an archaeologist who graduated from the National School of Anthropology and History (ENAH), with a master's degree in Humanities (Metropolitan Autonomous University) and a doctorate in Philosophy of Science (University of Guanajuato). My career in archaeology has focused on the study of the prehistory and rock art of Northern Mexico. Currently, my research focuses on the production processes of lithic industries in Northern Mexico, the origins of agriculture, the dispersal of maize during the Archaic period, and the technological organization of hunter-gatherer and semi-nomadic groups in North-Central Mexico. In the field of philosophical research, I delve into the historical analysis of the principles and methods of archaeology. I have explored patterns of evidential reasoning such as abduction, inference to the best explanation, and analogical reasoning. My current focus is on cognitive history and the history of epistemological and methodological ideas, specifically exploring the cognitive role of scientific measurement in the historical sciences and the pragmatism of John Dewey and Charles Peirce as applied to archaeology. As part of my activities within the Basic Academic Core (Núcleo Académico Básico) of the Doctorate in Social Anthropology at the EAHNM, I am interested in researching the cognitive processes involved in the formation of belief systems and the causes of belief change, primarily in ritual, educational, and scientific contexts.

References

Del Razo Canuto, J. C. (2024). La experiencia en la lógica de la investigación arqueológica. Valenciana. Estudios de Filosofía y Letras, 17(34): 7-33. https://doi.org/10.15174/rv.v17i34.771.

Dewey, J. (1977). The Logical Conditions of a Scientific Treatment of Morality. J. A. Boydston (ed.), The Middle Works of John Dewey, 1899–1924. Vol. 3: 1903-1906. Southern Illinois University Press: 3-39.

(1985). Context and Thought. J. A. Boydston (ed.), The Later Works of John Dewey, 1925-1953. Vol. 6: 1931-1932. Southern Illinois University Press: 3-21.

(2022). Lógica: la teoría de la investigación. Traducción de Á. M. Faerna. Prensas de la Universidad de Zaragoza.

Gaffney, C. F. (1987). Pragmatism: a Working Philosophy. C. F. Gaffney & V. L. Gaffney (eds.), Pragmatic Archaeology: Theory in Crisis? British Archaeological Reports: 11-16.

Gaffney, C. F. & V. L. Gaffney (eds.). (1987). Pragmatic Archaeology: Theory in Crisis? British Archaeological Reports.

Gallay, A. (1989). Logicism: a French View of Archaeological Theory Founded in Computational Perspective. Antiquity, 63(239): 27-39. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003598X00075554.

Gardin, J.-C. (1992). Semiotic Trends in Archaeology. J.-C. Gardin & C. S. Peebles (eds.), Representations in Archaeology. Indiana University Press: 87-104.

Gardin, J.-C. & M.-S. Lagrange. (1975). Essais d’analyse du discours archéologique. Éditions du CNRS.

Guillaumin, G. (2022). Del arte de la aceptación al arte del control: Dewey y la primera lógica de la investigación empírica. UAM-Iztapalapa / Gedisa.

(2023). La revolución silenciosa: expansión, reordenamiento e integración de la experiencia científica. UAM-Iztapalapa / Ediciones del Lirio.

Harris, O. J. T. & C. N. Cipolla. (2017). Archaeological Theory in the New Millennium: Introducing Current Perspectives. Routledge.

Hingley, R. (1987). Can We Have a Pragmatic Integrated Archaeology? C. F. Gaffney & V. L. Gaffney (eds.), Pragmatic Archaeology: Theory in Crisis? British Archaeological Reports: 89-106.

Hodder, I. (ed.). (1982). Symbolic and Structural Archaeology. Cambridge University Press.

(1986). Reading the Past: Current Approaches to Interpretation in Archaeology. Cambridge University Press.

Howard, R. J. (1982). Three Faces of Hermeneutics: an Introduction to Current Theories of Understanding. University of California Press.

Latour, B. (2005). Reassembling the Social: An Introduction to Actor-Network-Theory. Oxford University Press.

Laudan, L. (1997). La teoría de la investigación tomada en serio. A. Velasco Gómez (ed.), Racionalidad y cambio científico. Paidós: 25-41.

Nola, R. & Irzik, G. (2006). Philosophy, Science, Education and Culture. Springer.

Parmentier, R. J. (1994). Signs in Society: Studies in Semiotic Anthropology. Indiana University Press.

Peirce, C. S. (1932). Collected Papers of Charles Sanders Peirce. Vol. 2: Elements of Logic. C. Hartshorne & P. Weiss (eds.). Harvard University Press.

(1934). Collected Papers of Charles Sanders Peirce. Vol. 5: Pragmatism and Pragmaticism. C. Hartshorne & P. Weiss, (eds). Harvard University Press.

Preucel, R. W. (2006). Archaeological Semiotics. Blackwell.

(2016). Pragmatic Archaeology and Semiotic Mediation. Semiotic Review, 4. https://doi.org/10.71743/011mqm58.

Preucel, R. W. y A. A. Bauer. (2001). Archaeological Pragmatics. Norwegian Archaeological Review, 34(2): 85-96. https://doi.org/10.1080/00293650127469.

Preucel, R. W. y S. A. Mrozowski (eds.). (2010). Contemporary Archaeology in Theory: the New Pragmatism. Wiley-Blackwell.

Prown, J. D. (1993). The Truth of Material Culture: History or Fiction? S. Lubar & W. D. Kingery (eds.), History from Things: Essays on Material Culture. Smithsonian Institution Press: 1-19.

Rescher, N. (1978). Methodological Pragmatism: a Systems-Theoretic Approach to the Theory of Knowledge. Blackwell.

(2020). Methodological Pragmatism. W. J. González (ed.), Methodological Prospects for Scientific Research. Springer: 3-20.

Saitta, D. J. (2003). Archaeology and the Problems of Men. T. L. Van Pool & C. S. Van Pool (eds.), Essential Tensions in Archaeological Method and Theory. University of Utah Press: 11-24.

(2007). The Archaeology of Collective Action. University Press of Florida.

Urban, G. (1989). The Semiotics of Two Speech Styles in Shokleng. E. Mertz y R. J. Parmentier (eds.), Semiotic Mediation: Sociocultural and Psychological Perspectives. Academic Press: 311-329.

Wylie, A. (2007). Philosophy of Archaeology; Philosophy in Archaeology. S. Turner & M. Risjord (eds.), Philosophy of Anthropology and Sociology. Elsevier: 517-549.

Yorston, R. M., C. F. Gaffney y V. L. Gaffney. (1987). A Manifesto for Pragmatic Archaeology. C. F. Gaffney & V. L. Gaffney (eds.), Pragmatic Archaeology: Theory in Crisis? British Archaeological Reports: 107-114.

Published
2026-11-14
How to Cite
Del Razo Canuto, J. C. (2026). Reconstructing Inquiry: A Pragmatist Perspective on the Logic of Archaeological Knowledge. Open Insight, 17(41), 75-97. https://doi.org/10.23924/oi.v17i41.761